Having watched the movie Autumn in New York couple of times, I could easily say it's an slow movie which not all would prefer to watch. So, an IMDB rating of 4.7 is understandable.
Autumn in New York was released in 2000 and couple of years from then A Walk to Remember was released. Same storyline but in an school/college environment. But, an IMDB rating of 7.1. How come?
Whatever may be I like Autumn in New York of these two and Mandy Moore.